Christmas Baked Salmon: Easy & Make-ahead

Your Christmas main course for this year is on the shelves! ! Have you ever seen such festive grilled salmon? It’s easy!
First published in December 2020, this Christmas cookbook was an instant hit with readers. A baked salmon butter honey glaze covered in a creamy dill sauce and topped with a festive “tapeen sauce”, it pays off with minimal effort.

Festive Baked Salmon!

Every year I try to come up with a Christmas main course that you can make that is super easy, but still has that extra wow factor that will make you the star of Christmas dinner…

This is it that I found this year: Holiday Salmon!

They are:

Baked with a honey garlic glaze;

Spread with creamy dill sauce;

Filled with a festive “band” of dried cranberries, almonds and parsley; and

Finally, it’s pomegranates, for festive color and lots of fresh lemon juice.

What an alliance of flavors and textures! It’s mostly salty with a hint of sweetness, and the creamy dill sauce is a natural accompaniment to the salmon.
Finally, holiday tapenade toppings celebrate the holidays!

Can I stress enough the ease of manufacture? continue reading!

Overview: How to make Christmas Baked Salmon

1. Simmer 3-ingredient Honey Glaze for 2 minutes;
2. Pour over salmon then bake wrapped in foil (easy clean up!);
3. Spread cooked salmon with 4-ingredient Lemon Dill Sauce, 4-ingredient “Tapenade” (topping mix);
4. Sprinkle with pomegranate seeds, drizzle with lemon juice;
5. Serve warm or at room temperature. Now sit back and bask in praise!

What you need for this Festive Baked Salmon

Here’s what you need for this festive Baked Salmon.

1. SIDE OF SALMON

• This is one side of a whole salmon. It should not be flavoured or pre-marinated in any way. If frozen, thaw thoroughly overnight in the fridge covered, and then pat dry very well (frozen fish gets watery);
• Skin on – for easier handling. Once cooked, the skin will hold the salmon together. Without it, there’s a higher change the flesh flakes open when transferring to the tray. Interestingly, I have never seen a side of salmon sold without skin – this may well be the reason; and
• Bones removed – Your fishmonger should have already done this, but just double check. Run your fingers across the surface, especially along the mid-line (where the spine was) where pin bone culprits sometimes hide. Check the belly section carefully too. If there are bones, use fish boning tweezers or just personal grooming tweezers to pull them out (pinch and yank with conviction!). Clean small pliers also work.

2. HONEY GLAZE FOR SALMON

This is used to bake the salmon so it gets infused with incredible sweet-buttery-garlicky flavour while it bakes. Here’s what you need:

To make the Honey Glaze, all you do is plonk everything in a saucepan and simmer for a couple of minutes to thicken slightly and bring all the flavours together.

3. BAKING THE SALMON

The salmon is baked in foil which is handy for minimal clean up, but actually the main reason is because it holds the glaze around the salmon better while it bakes!

Here’s how the salmon is cooked:

1. Line a tray with foil. (Recommended: A double layer of foil for leakage protection.) Then baking/parchment paper. Place the salmon on top.
2. Fold the foil sides up a bit to cup them a little so the glaze won’t spill onto the tray. Pour the glaze over (it’s fine that the glaze is still hot);
3. Top with another sheet of paper and then foil. Seal edges to form a parcel. No need to make it tightly sealed, just mostly sealed is fine;
4. Bake for 15 minutes covered;
5. Uncover, then switch oven to broiler/grill. Grill for 10 minutes to get some tasty caramelisation on the edges and a bit on the surface. IMPORTANT: Keep salmon on the middle shelf in the oven when broiling/grilling, don’t move it closer to the heat source – risk of paper burning!

It smells SO GOOD when it’s in the oven…. and here’s what the Baked Salmon looks like when it comes out!

Immediately transfer to serving platter using the paper overhang (otherwise the salmon will keep cooking on the tray), either lifting or sliding it off. And here’s how to remove the foil and paper from under the salmon – just tear and slide!

HOW TO REMOVE FOIL AND PAPER FROM UNDER THE BAKED SALMON

The salmon must be chilled for at least 10 minutes at this point or the lemon dill dressing will melt right away. This salmon dish is also excellent served warm rather than hot, and can even be served at room temperature. It’s so convenient because you can make it really hot without worrying about exact cooking times!

4. LEMON DILL SAUCE FOR SALMON

This sour cream-based sauce provides an element of creamy richness to the baked salmon as well as acting as the “glue” for the Holiday “Tapenade” we pile over the top. Not including dill was never an option – it is, after all, best friends with salmon!

Note: we only use the zest in the sour cream sauce because we deliberately want to keep it very thick and “paste-like” so we can slather it on thickly. The rest is used to liberally douse the finished dish for some welcome tang. It’s an essential step!

4. HOLIDAY “TAPENADE“

This jumble of goodies (which I call a “Holiday Tapenade”) is a terrific combination for both flavours and textures with the Honey Glazed salmon and Creamy Dill Sauce. The sweet, slightly tart cranberries and the nutty almonds contrast beautifully with the cooling Creamy Dill Sauce and the rich, Honey Glazed flesh of the salmon.

Here’s what you need for the Holiday Tapenade:

• Pomegranate – This is what we use to sprinkle across the finished dish for their jewel-like festive colour, and of course for great pops of tart juiciness!
• Dried cranberries – In the spirit of holidays and also for the tart/sweet profile rather than just plain sweetness that other dried fruits have. Alternatives (in order of suggestion): Dried sour cherries, golden raisins, normal raisins or sultanas;
• Orange juice – This is used to soak the cranberries in order to reconstitute them and plump them up. Otherwise, they’re rather shrivelled and chewy. Because this is, after all, for a special occasion why not one more step to make the cranberries extra special! As mentioned, it’s mainly for the cranberries, but the orange juice also adds a touch of extra sweetness and citrusy flavour – very on-theme for holidays! Substitute with any fruit juice you wish. Apple would especially be great – otherwise just use water with a dollop of honey or maple syrup;
• Slivered almonds – Purchased already cut into slivers (else sliver blanched almonds yourself), this is a lovely shape that you can use as-is. We also give them a quick toasting to boost the nuttiness and bronze them. Alternatives: Almonds (preferably blanched), pistachios, hazelnuts, pecans, macadamias, walnuts;
• Parsley for freshness and the green colour for Christmas!
• Olive oil to add just a bit of richness and bring it all together.

Make ahead option: Make the Tapenade up to 2 days ahead but leave the almonds out until just before serving. Almonds can be toasted ahead, just store them in the pantry until required.

5. ASSEMBLING

And here’s how the Christmas Baked Salmon is assembled:

1. Smother the salmon generously with the Creamy Dill Sauce. Generous is the operative word here! It’s the main sauce for this dish, and it’s also the “glue” for the Tapenade;
2. Sprinkle the Tapenade across the surface. Really pile it on, use it all!;
3. Then sprinkle over the pomegranate next, and finally the lemon juice (the Tapenade will catch it); and
4. Voila! Presentation! Applause! Compliments! Bows!

How to serve this Christmas Baked Salmon

Put the whole salmon on the plate as shown in the picture above, let everyone enjoy its beauty.

Then you can either cut it into portions – literally just use a knife to cut it – or let everyone help themselves. I find it easiest to use a cake server for actually lifting slices to serve easily, so you might like to also provide something like this if you’re allowing guests to serve themselves.

I feel like this has been a really long post for something that I stated is a really easy recipe. And I still promise it is!

It’s just that a side of salmon is not cheap, and is the sort of thing we splurge on for special occasions. So I want to arm you with enough information and details to ensure you feel the confidence of knowing that you will nail this dish – even if you’re not that experienced in the kitchen.

Hand on heart, there is very little that can go wrong with this recipe. The only real pitfall will be if you overcook the salmon. However salmon is a forgiving meat because it’s an oily fish, so it’s really not the end of the world even if you do take it too far. But if you really want to be sure you’ve got it right, you can always use a meat thermometer (see recipe notes for internal temperatures).